Top 8 Pizza Places in Fort Myers, Florida

Photo by Engin Akyurt from Pexels

Whether you’re a local or just visiting Fort Myers, Florida, at some point, you’ll want a tasty pizza. From deep-dish to thin-crust pizzas, here are our recommendations for the top eight places to get the best pizza in the Fort Myers, Florida area.

Downtown House of Pizza

1520 Hendry St, Fort Myers, Florida

You can watch your pizza being made in the open-air kitchen when you dine at Downtown House of Pizza. This restaurant serves authentic New York-style pizza with fresh-made dough, homemade sauces, and the freshest toppings. You can always build your pizza or branch out and try one of Downtown House of Pizza’s specialty pies, such as the Sweet Meat or Chicken Bacon Ranch.

If you’re allergic to gluten or trying to reduce your gluten intake, you can order your pizza with gluten-free dough or even with a cauliflower crust. Vegans can also get dairy-free cheese as a topping. 

Capone’s Coal Fired Pizza

2225 First St, Fort Myers, Florida

You’ll feel like you’re part of the mafia when you eat at Capone’s Coal Fired Pizza. Photographs and memorabilia of the infamous gangster Al Capone and other mafia members who worked in Chicago during the 1920s and 1930s line the walls of this restaurant.

Capone’s Coal Fired Pizza cooks its pizza in an 800-degree coal-fired oven. This cooking method ensures a crispy crust for your pizza. Try the restaurant’s specialty pizzas, like the Tommy Gun or Mobster White, to stay in the mafia-themed vibe. 

Maria’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

1224 SE 46th Ln, Cape Coral, Florida

Voted as one of the best pizza places in Cape Coral, Maria’s Pizzeria & Restaurant serves authentic Italian pizza and food. You can smell the fresh garlic and Romano cheese as soon as you walk into this fine establishment.

Nothing beats a classic Margherita pizza with fresh basil and mozzarella cheese, but you can also savor a meat-filled pizza with Maria’s Deluxe. If you want, you can order your pizza with a gluten-free or cauliflower crust. Stop by to enjoy one of Maria’s Pizzeria & Restaurant’s fabulous pizzas.

Chicago Pizza

1341 SE 47th Terrace, Cape Coral, Florida 

Chicago Pizza is another favorite Cape Coral pizzeria, and it makes delicious thin-crust and deep-dish pizzas that will delight any palate. For over 30 years, Chicago Pizza has served pizza, sandwiches with Italian beef or sausage, and refreshing salads to locals and visitors. Try traditional-style pizzas like the meat or vegetarian or indulge in a Chicago White Out pizza made with garlic, olive oil, ricotta, and mozzarella. You can also build your pizza on a gluten-free or cauliflower crust with your choice of exciting toppings, like broccoli or banana peppers. 

Citrola’s on College

8841 College Pkwy, Fort Myers, Florida

When you dine at Citrola’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria location, you’ll see why loyal customers have gone there for pizza and subs for over 20 years. Citrola’s on College has been on College Parkway since 2011, and it is a local favorite.

The dough and bread used for Citrola’s food are handmade daily, as are its secret pizza sauces. You’ll find only fresh ingredients on your pizza, like freshly made ricotta and mozzarella cheeses. Savor New York-style pizzas like the Mediterranean with black olives and feta cheese or the White Clams Casino with chopped clams, bacon, and oregano. 

Joe Daddy’s Pizza

2481 Del Prado Blvd N, Cape Coral, Florida | 3015 SW Pine Island Rd, Cape Coral, Florida

With two locations in Cape Coral, you can always get your favorite Joe Daddy’s Pizza. The pizza makers at Joe Daddy’s Pizza have dough and sauce production down to a science. 

Build your pizza with toppings such as jalapeno peppers, sausage, and ricotta cheese. You’ll also want to try one of the house specialties like The Napoli, which has bacon, ham, black olives, and mushrooms as toppings. Or you can try The Hawaiian, which has pineapple, ham, and bacon as toppings. 

Lelulo’s Pizza

3123 Chiquita Blvd S, Cape Coral, Florida

For Pittsburgh-style pizza, head over to Lelulo’s Pizza. Its brick-oven baked pizzas have thick crusts that perfectly hold the cheese, sauce, and toppings. Not only can you have classic pizzas like a Margherita, but you can order unusual and quirky pizzas like the Hogs, Horns, and Hens topped with bacon, steak, and chicken. You may also want to try the Taco Pizza with ground beef, beans, lettuce, and tomato served with a side of salsa.

For something different, try one of Lelulo’s Pizza salads, which can come topped with french fries, just like some salads you’ll find in Pittsburgh. You can also get fat calzone and stromboli to satisfy any Italian food craving. Stop by 3123 Chiquita Blvd. S in Cape Coral for a unique pizza from Lelulo’s Pizza.

Nice Guys Pizza 

1404 Cape Coral Pkwy East, Cape Coral, Florida

Whether you want a hearty meat pizza or a sophisticated one with upscale toppings, you’ll find just what you’re looking for at Nice Guys Pizza. You can order vegan pizzas with dairy-free cheese and toppings like tikka masala sauce, nutritional yeast, or crushed olives.

Have fun eating a specialty pizza, like the Truffle Shuffle, topped with cremini onions and black truffle oil. Branch out and try The Washington Carver pizza with peanut sauce, applewood smoked bacon and raspberry jam. Consider The Cuban with mustard wine sauce, pulled pork, and pickles. 

Best Pizza in Fort Myers, Florida

Our team at Fort Myers Mitsubishi bets you’re craving a hot slice of pizza right now. Which pizza joint is your favorite and why? What’s the most unusual pizza you’ve tried? Is there a hidden gem of a pizza restaurant that we missed? If you can recommend one, feel free to let us know, and we’ll add it to the list.

In the meantime, check out our new and used inventory, although we require some information upfront. And if your vehicle needs routine service, get in touch with our professional technicians at our Mitsubishi Service Center.